Exploring the Role of the Fu Dao Yuan in Enhancing the Cultural and Social Experiences of International Students in China

Informing this qualitative study were 45 international students in a top-tier comprehensive research university in southeast China. The study focuses on the experience of international students towards the role played by international Fu Dao Yuan (Counselor) in enhancing the students’ cultural and social experiences at the university. The results revealed four most significant adjustment issues for international students. Building on the U-Curve adjustment theory (Oberg, 1960), the study discovered the importance of international Fu Dao Yuan to provide cultural and social support to international students for easy adjustment into a new culture and social setting. The study bears practical implications as to providing international Fu Dao Yuan with important insights that help to create an environment conducive for enhancing the cultural and social experiences of international students.

political education" this major emphasizes theories instead of practice to the occupation of student affairs administration. To get more practical skills, many Fu Dao Yuans are studying for the certificate of psychological consultants and career development mentors (Li & Fang, 2017;Lin & Peng, 2003;Zoe, 2017).

2.1Approaches to International Student Services
Despite many transformations to the higher education system in China since the 1990s, many ideas of the centralized planned system, inspired by Russian system in the early 1950s still exist in contemporary Chinese university system, for example, Chinese universities have a centralized model of administration where all international students are admitted into a single faculty of international education. Although, international students take courses in different faculties of their academic specialization but all their services are provided by staffs at the faculty of international education (Liu & Lin, 2016).
Chinese universities have adopted a vertical network system to provide services to students, in other word, it is called parental or Nanny style of service provision (Liu & Lin, 2016). Upon admission of international students in every department there is a Fu Dao Yuan for international students who is in charge and responsible of full spectrum of issues concerning international students. International Fu Dao Yuan is a single stop shop of services for all international students; international students do not need to worry about students' visa application, medical insurance purchase, contact with migration office, moral education to their day-to-day living and connection with the hospitals in case of any emergency. International Fu Dao Yuans also make sure international students are registered for the right courses, meet all requirements for graduations and are comfortable living in student residences (Liu & Lin, 2016). If necessary, student financial aid offices also should send the financial-aid policies to the international Fu Dao Yuans, and then international Fu Dao Yuans help the needy students to apply. In addition, the cell phones of international Fu Dao Yuans are supposed to operate 24/7 for students under their care (Liu & Lin, 2016;Zoe, 2017). This is the reason why it is called a vertical network system or parental/nanny approach to students' services.

Cultural and Social Problems Encountered by International Students
Once international students encountered a problem or had any issue, they will report to the international Fu Dao Yuan of the department. If this issue was beyond the capacity of the international Fu Dao Yuan to resolve, international Fu Dao Yuan had to report to the faculty administrator in charge of student affairs, also, if the faculty administrator could not resolve the problem within the faculty, it was channelled to the dean of students at the institutional level (Li & Fang, 2017;Lin & Peng, 2003). The duties of international Fu Dao Yuans include everything about international student life. It is a complicated duty because it's impossible for a single person to solve all the problems alone (Zoe, 2017). International Fu Dao Yuans only get assistance from faculty administrators or deans of students at the institutional level when the issue is very serious. So, the system places much pressure on the shoulders of international Fu Dao Yuans and it is challenging to distinguish special cases from trivial ones (Liu & Lin, 2016;Zoe, 2017).
In spite of using the parental/Nanny approach to provide services to international students in Chinese universities, research on international students in China reveal that although international students have high educational aspirations and positive attitudes toward their education, they still experienced significant problems in adjusting to the host culture and social milieu. (Dervin et al, 2018;Li, 2015;Yang, 2018). The cultural difference, language barrier, lack of social interaction with host students, food incompatibilities, internet restriction, and lack of counselling services for international students were widely recognized in many works of literature as the major problems for international students in China. (Chen, 1999;Gaw, 2000;Wen, 2005;Yost & Lucas, 2002). Wen (2005) and Yost & Lucas (2002) noted that inadequate cultural experience and lack of social support mechanisms of international students created obstacles in social integration with host people. These obstacles led international students to begin experiencing situations of uneasiness that were detrimental to their individual psychology such as feelings of isolation, loneliness, and frustration (Yang, 2018;Zhai, 2002). These problems could be seen as culture shock: "a psychological disorientation experienced by people who suddenly enter radically different cultural environments to live or work" (Oberg, 1960). The roles and Endeavour of international Fu Dao Yuans are inevitable to enhance culture and social experiences of international students in China.

3.Theoretical Approach
The theoretical background of this paper hinges on the Oberg (1960) U-Curve adjustment theory (UCT). Specifically, it portrays the transition and adaptation process from old culture to new culture, as well as the social life. According to UCT model, the transition and adaptation process goes through four stages. The honeymoon stage occurs during the first to third weeks after arrival at the host country; individuals are fascinated by the new environment and different culture. The initial cultural obsession is followed by a second stage of disillusionment and frustration, which is culture shock stage. The newcomer starts to encounter frustration and irritation towards the host country and people after experiencing the culture on daily basis. The third stage is the adjustment stage in Journal of Education and Practice www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1735 (Paper) ISSN 2222-288X (Online) Vol.11, No.31, 2020 45 which the individual gradually adapts to the new norms and values of the host country after being exposed into cultural and social support mechanisms. At this stage individual can act more appropriately than they were before. Finally, is the mastery stage, is characterized by additional increase in the individual's ability to function effectively in the new culture and social settings. (see Figure 1). (Black & Mendenha, 1990;Lysgaard, 1955;Oberg, 1960). As it was suggested on the third stage of U-Curve adjustment theory (Oberg, 1960), the model was appropriate for exploring how the international Fu Dao Yuans played an important role in enhancing the cultural and social experiences of international students in China. Figure 1. The U-Curve adjustment pattern (Adapted from Oberg, 1960)

4.Methods
The study employed a qualitative design, as it was an empirical research that aimed to reveal the experiences of international student in China beyond those that might be already predicted. To achieve the research aim, in-depth focus-group interviews were employed as a relevant approach in accessing different categories of information, such as motivations, thoughts and understandings of participants (Coles &Swami, 2012).

Research Design
The research design selected for the study was an embedded single-case approach (Yin, 2018), thus being helpful for showing a multifaceted picture of cultural and social experiences of international students in a chosen university. One top-tier comprehensive research university in southeast China was selected as a site for the study because it had promoted internalization. The institutional site was a public university, ranked in the top twenty of over 2000 Chinese universities. The institution had a total enrolment of approximately 40,000 students, including 3,500 international students from over130 countries and regions (University Prospectus, 2019).

Participants
A convenient sample of 45 male and female international students participated in the study. The participation was voluntary such that the students were willing and enthusiastic to share better insights about cultural and social experiences. Table 1

Data Collection and Ethical Considerations
To ensure the data collected attain the research aim, ethical considerations were significant in undertaking this study. The informed consent letter for participation was provided at the beginning of each focus-group interview and all students were given enough time to read and understand before focus-group discussion. Participants were allowed to withdraw at any time. 45 international students from sixteen countries were recruited for nine focus groups and each group contained no more than five participants.

Data Analysis and Trustworthiness
In spite of sharing their thoughts in focus group, during data analysis each participant was treated as a separate case. The pattern matching method as an attempt to link an existing pattern that derived from theory, with collected information (Alebeek & Wilson, 2019;Trochim, 1989), was applied to compare the revealed description of cultural and social experiences of international students with U-curve adjustment theory. Cases were analysed from the coded transcriptions of each participant and later categorized into themes by adopting inductive coding (Thomas, 2003). This helped to condense wide and varied raw data through constant comparison into a brief format to form a single theme. The whole set of data was transcribed and coded by the interviewers (both authors). To ensure the trustworthiness of data, member checking (Lincoln & Guba, 1985) was applied; the transcripts were sent back to the participants to prove that the respondents' experiences were represented as intended.

Global Contact Zone and Nanny style of Service Provision
In general, participants appreciated the opportunities and experiences of studying in China. The majority of participants described the university as a global educational contact zone. The students from around the world meet, interact and learn from each other. Chris a student from Congo noted that: Coming to study in China has helped me to meet people from different part of the World. China is like min globe…when you are in touch with people from other places, you learn a lot…. The more you spend time with different people from different countries, the more you discover things and experience different cultures Other international students commented on how the Nanny style of service provision was helpful in their daily life. International Fu Dao Yuan as a single stop shop of services for international students took all responsibility about international student life, while students only need to passively receive services. Zak a student Journal of Education and Practice www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1735 (Paper) ISSN 2222-288X (Online) Vol.11, No.31, 2020 47 from France noted that: The style of service provision used by Fu Dao Yuans is very proactive…I was very happy when I realized Fu Dao Yuans are responsible for such issues assigned up for the right courses, visa application, arranging student's residences, purchase of medical insurance and so on…this kind of system simplifies my life here in the university. However, some participants also think critically about the risks involved in the Nanny style of service provision, which could prevent the students from being proactive in finding out how various services in Chinese universities works and how to access them on their own. Kate a student from Canada explained: The style of service provision used by Fu Dao Yuans is very good, but I think to some extent it limits us to manage our own school and life issues as independent adults…. It makes us to have little experience on how things work, because things that can be handled by students themselves such as to make sure we sign up for the right courses, meet all requirements for graduations and so on, are done by international Fu Dao Yuans. Echoing the findings of Liu and Lin (2016) and Zoe (2017), most often the duties of international Fu Dao Yuans are complicated because it's impossible for a single person to solve all the problems encountered by students. The system exerts much pressure on the shoulders of international Fu Dao Yuans and it's a real challenge to differentiate special issues from trivial ones. This trend was reflected by many participants who believed that the international Fu Dao Yuans, in charge of different departments, had limited role in enhancing the cultural and social experience of international students because of its numerous duties. The system weaves all students and makes it difficult for international Fu Dao Yuan to focus on cultural and social programs for international students. The findings revealed that the language challenges, social interaction with Chinese students, cultural orientation programs, counselling services for international students, were the four most significant adjustment issues for international students.

Language challenges
Language challenges were the most mentioned issue by many respondents, as it limits the cultural and social experiences of international students. Participants revealed inadequate efforts taken by international Fu Dao Yuans to promote different programs and activities in favour of language learning. Leonard from Nigeria illustrated: Still there are limited efforts taken by international Fu Dao Yuans to create a conducive and alternative environment for us to master the language. For example, there is no active language exchange program to enable mutual learning with host students, where Chinese students could learn foreign languages and we could also learn Chinese language easily.

Cultural orientation for international students
Respondents reported that the international Fu Dao Yuans had little focus on providing cultural orientation programs to address cultural differences within the university. The orientation programs were mainly focused on academics; for example, how to use the library, course selection and another academic services. Most of the students usually consulted their fellow senior international students regarding their difficulties in adjusting to a new culture, although the senior students also had the similar adjustment issues. Clara from UK described how orientation programs played a little role in enhancing the culture and social experience of international students in the university. Before I came to China, I had no idea how life could be in university, but I was expecting the orientation programs could easily help me to get familiar with host culture and social life. But I think the orientation programs are not focused much on enhancing the cultural and social experiences of international students… They emphasize much on academic orientation.

Social interaction with Chinese Students
The international students revealed that they felt very isolated from Chinese students and culture. These kinds of experience led to frustration, confusion and emotional discomfort among the international students because they lack familiar signs and belonging. Responses show that there were few effective programs to bridge international and Chinese students. For example, active extracurricular activities for international and Chinese students, to help them easily get to know each other. Some students admitted to have been involved in some programs designed by international Fu Dao Yuans to bring international and Chinese students together for the purpose of sharing their culture, but most of those programs lacked effectiveness and were not efficient. Shab from India stated: One time, I got information from Fu Dao Yuan of our department about the social program called the English-Chinese corner. In that program international and Chinese students could come together to learn the languages and cultures of each other by playing some interesting games while speaking both English and Chinese languages, also it could help students to make friends. Honestly, it was a nice program but it lacked effectiveness and seriousness which made many students to lost interest in attending the program.

Counselling services for international students
Commenting on their experiences in the counselling programs for international students with cultural differences, the majority of participants identified counselling as one of the most important factors in enhancing cultural and social experiences; therefore, designing counselling programs to help international students who felt very isolated from Chinese students and culture, those who experience frustration, confusion and emotional discomfort would help them easily adapt to the host culture and social settings. Angel from Ghana stated: I really appreciate the services provided by international Fu Dao Yuans; they are really helpful. But they should also consider having counselling programs for international students just as what they have for Chinese students. It will easily facilitate adjustment into the new cultural and social life. Other participants mentioned the lack of awareness on counselling services available for them. Abdul from Pakistan argued that: Frankly speaking, I have no idea where I can seek professional counselling services in the University. The office which I frequently use is the office of international Fu Dao Yuan, for issues like course registration, visa application and so on, but not for counselling services.

Discussion
This article examined the role played by the student affairs office in supporting international students to have successful cultural and social experiences based on their perceptions and experiences in China. Many studies about international students in China integrated the academic and culture experience of international students. The study has differentiated them, considering how they are important in different ways. The U-Curve adjustment theory (Oberg, 1960) was employed particularly in its stage of adjustment, to examine the adjustment trajectory of international students in a new culture. The study discovered that the international Fu Dao Yuans in Chinese universities are central in the enhancement of cultural and social experiences of international students; because it confirmed that there was a connection between international Fu Dao Yuans and international students. The office of international Fu Dao Yuans was the most used office by international students who sought services such as visa application, course registration, traveling, legal problems, purchase of health insurance, comfortable living standards in student residences, and so on. Providing cultural and social support to international students in order to successfully enhance their status is vital and deserves further attention in many Chinese universities. The cultural and social support should not only be for the positive well-being of international students but also for helping them to cope with the host culture and society. By placing great emphasis on language and communication programs, cultural orientation for international students, social interaction and counselling services for international students, this will help the international students from whatever background to easy adjustment to the host culture and society. With a completely enhancement status, the international students will not only accept the host country's customs but will also begin to enjoy its social life and studies.

Practical Recommendations
Given the recent increase of international students in Chinese higher education coming from diverse backgrounds, the process of cultivating international Fu Dao Yuans in Chinese universities should go together with the increasing level of international students in China so as to be able to have enough international Fu Dao Yuans with manageable duties. This will help them to have much focus on cultural and social programs for international students. The practical recommendations developed from international students' experiences are essential for international Fu Dao Yuans interested in enhancing the culture and social experiences of international students in China.
Firstly, the international Fu Dao Yuans must ensure that the orientation programs for international students are not primarily focused on academic programs but should also focus on enhancing the cultural and social experiences of the international students. Enhancing cultural experience in Universities can be achieved by designing orientation programs which promotes easy adjustment of international students into the host culture. Huntley (1993) stated that a well-organized orientation can also help international students become aware of aspects of university life and then make a better adjustment. Furthermore, Pedersen (1991) stated that, "orientation is a continuous process requiring contact with students before they arrive and during their stay", therefore, the study suggested that the educational and cultural information about host universities must be made more readily available to prospective international students before they leave their home countries so that they can be prepared or at least be aware of the differences before leaving.
Secondly, improving counselling services for international students; the study confirmed that many international students were not aware of counselling services available to them. Under these circumstances, it is important for international Fu Dao Yuans to create better connections with international students in terms of personal emotional issues, so that they can openly share their feelings and indicate if they need any help. Pedersen (1991) presented an alternative technique of providing counselling services to international students, which is beyond the formal counselling technique. He recommends a harmonizing system of informal methods, for instance, going to where the students live or hang out, whether at home, on campus benches, hallways, or street corners and taking part in social actions.
Thirdly, strengthening language support; many international students are still facing several difficulties in using the host language for communication. For instance, the study discovered that participants consider the Chinese language as the main challenge, to cope with host environment. International Fu Dao Yuans should go beyond the one-semester host language course and design continuing programs such as mini communication workshops which could help to reveal some commonly used words in the social and academic setting to international students. Furthermore, Robinson (1992) suggested making the implicit cultural knowledge explicit in their instruction. This is providing opportunities to develop essential knowledge on the host culture. Therefore, the integration of cultural and academic guidance while teaching is vital in enhancing international students' cultural competence.
Lastly, international Fu Dao Yuans should help to create interaction opportunities between host students and international students. Zhai (2002) argued that international students who spent more of their leisure time with host students are significantly better adapted than those who spent more leisure time with their fellow country mate. A variety of active and efficient programs such as English-Chinese conversation programs, culture clubs, and international festivals could be designed by international Fu Dao Yuans to enhance cultural and social experience of international students.

Limitations and Further Research
Practically, and within the constraints of research, the study recruited only international students in a single University to share their experiences. It is therefore suggested that future research could further investigate students' experiences and international Fu Dao Yuan activities in many Chinese Universities. Participant's experiences might differ from those of students in other well-developed institutions which are considered as world-class universities. The study encourages future research to be carried out by using various methods such as quantitative or mixed-methods research which could provide a better understanding and richer data on the cultural and social experiences of international students in China.